Sunday, November 3, 2013

Why does the tinker throw away the chrysanthemums?(i.e. What is the significance of that act--for him and for Elisa?) John Steinbeck's "The...

When the tinker arrives on the Allen farm, his main
objective is to be able to repair something so that he can earn money.  After Elisa
tells him that she has nothing in need of repair, he does not leave; instead, he uses
his skills as a salesman and opportunist by cajoling her into talking about her beloved
chrysanthemums.  When he sounds poetic in his description of them--"Looks like a quick
puff of colored smoke"--Elisa's aesthetic nature is awakened and excited.  Of course,
the tinker then takes advantage of this awakening and feigns an interest in the flowers,
saying that he would love to take some to a lady down the road that he
knows.


With shining eyes and an awakened spirit, Elisa
gladly puts some of the chrysanthemums in a pot for the tinker to give to his friend. 
As he drives off after Elisa has given him some work, she feels alive and encouraged
that he will give the flowers to the lady.  However, as she and her husband travel the
road later on their way to supper in town, Elisa spots the discarded chrysanthemums on
the side of the road. 


Elisa feels betrayed at the sight of
the mutilated chrysanthemums. She turns from her husband so that he will not see her
crying "weakly--like an old woman."  Elisa has been humiliated by the sight of the
flower for which she has become so excited in its promise of bloom and life; instead,
her aesthetic passion and connection of spirit with nature has been ridiculed and
sullied.  Towards both men, the tinker and her husband, she is now
frustrated.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Film: 'Crocodile Dundee' directed by Peter FaimanHow are stereotypical roles upheld and challenged?

One of the stereotypes that is both upheld and challenged is the role of the damsel in distress. Sue is supposed to be the delic...