Wednesday, September 9, 2015

What impression does Mayella Ewell make when she is on the witness stand in To Kill a Mockingbird?

A highly sympathetic character, Mayella Ewell proves to be
a confused and emotional young woman when she testifies in the trial of Tom Robinson in
To Kill a Mockingbird. The lonely and friendless daughter of Bob
Ewell, Mayella spends her life taking care of her younger brothers and sisters while Bob
is away drinking and causing trouble. Tom appears to be the only person who shows her
any sympathy, volunteering to do chores for her on occasion. But when she tries to show
her affection by groping and kissing him, Tom (a married man) beats a retreat. But Bob
sees him first, and it is he that beats Mayella for her indiscretion with a black man.
Mayella, weak and fearful of her father, apparently agrees to back Bob's story of Tom
raping her.


Mayella is out of place in the courtroom--and
probably any public setting--and she mistakes Atticus' polite civility for mocking
insults. She has never been called "ma'am" or "Miss Mayella" before (except possibly by
Tom), and she seems intimidated by the men in the courtroom. Her confusion of the events
comes in part from her lack of education, and she is never able to get her story
straight. First she says that Tom hit her, then that he didn't, and finally decides that
she can't remember. When Atticus asked her how Tom raped her, Mayella
replied,



"I
don't know how he done it, but he done
it.



Atticus "rained questions
on her," and the frightened Mayella had no answers. She finally summoned the strength to
call all the "fine fancy gentlemen" in the courtroom "yellow, stinkin' cowards," and
then said no more. Scout thought that


readability="7">

I guess if she hadn't been so poor and ignorant,
Judge Taylor would have put her under the jail for the contempt she showed everybody in
the courtroom.



A character
deserving of great pity, Mayella loses the sympathy of the reader by turning on the one
man who had showed her kindness, and the lies she tells about Tom eventually costs him
his life.

Please help me argue against this statement: "Violence is never justified as a form of public protest."The topic ‘Violence is never justified as...

Perhaps the best way to approach this would be to point to
places like Libya or Syria, or South Africa in the Apartheid era.  Looking at countries
like those, you could argue that there are clearly times when violence is justifiable
because the government is so oppressive and because it offers so little in the way of
opportunities for non-violent political expression.  (If you really want to go all-out,
just ask rhetorically whether it would have been right for Jews to engage in violent
protest in Nazi Germany.)


Now, it will be hard to argue
that the London riots were caused by these sorts of conditions.  Even underprivileged
youths in Britain have the right to express themselves politically and are relatively
unoppressed by the government.  However, you could argue that the British political
system allows youths to be heard, but never gives them what they demand.  You could
argue that police activities are oppressive in a country where the police treat other
people so well.  In this way, you could argue (if you have to) that the London riots
were justified.


Even if the London riots were not
justified, it seems clear that there are times when violence is
justified.

Tuesday, September 8, 2015

What is civic nationalism?

Civic nationalism is, in a way, a positive vision of what
nationalism should be.  It is one that is based on citizenship and legal rights, not on
biology.


One form of nationalism is based on race.  In this
form of nationalism, people should feel tied to one another because they are of the same
"race" or ethnicity.  In this sort of nationalism, no one can choose to belong or not to
belong to some nation.  They are in that nation because of their
birth.


By contrast, civic nationalism is based on choices
we make.  If I go to Canada and I want to embrace the values and attitudes of Canada,
then I can be a Canadian.  I do not have to be of any particular ethnic group to be
included as a Canadian.  All I have to do is to buy into the attitudes that make a
person Canadian and then make the choice to become a Canadian
citizen.


These are very different views of what should tie
us together.  In ethnic nationalism, we are tied together by our "blood."  In civic
nationalism, we are tied together by our values, our attitudes and our
choices.

Monday, September 7, 2015

Did the examples of foreshadowing help you predict what happened in "The Leap"?

Foreshadowing is a difficult thing to do well, because it
should provide us with clues as to what will happen but forshadowing should be something
that we are only aware of when the ending actually comes and we can see what has been
foreshadowed and predicted. The mark of an excellent author then is one who is able to
use foreshadowing but only make us aware of it at the end of the story, causing us to
read back and look at these predictions again.


I must
admit, when I first read this excellent story, this happened to me, and I was blind to
how the author was using foreshadowing to indicate what was going to happen. Looking
back at the story, my favourite piece of foreshadowing is the
following:



My
mother once said that I'd be amazed at how many things a person can do within the act of
falling.



This of course
foreshadows the narrator's own act of falling as she is saved by her mother at the end
of the story. Therefore, I wasn't aware of these examples of foreshadowing until I had
finished the story and so it didn't help me make any
predictions.

How did the American people use the social contract idea to justify the Revolution?

To understand this, look at the words of the Declaration
of Independence.


In that document, Thomas Jefferson tells
us that the reason for government is to protect the "life, liberty, and pursuit of
happiness" of its people.  Furthermore, the government only gets its "just power" from
the consent of the people.  This is a classic statement of the idea of social contract. 
It says that people consent to have a government so that it will protect their
rights.


Jefferson goes on to say that the British
government had stopped protecting the people's rights and was, instead, infringing on
them.  Because of that, he said, the people had the right to rebel.  In other words, the
government had broken the social contract and rebellion was, therefore,
justified.

In "Through The Tunnel" what is the function of Jerry's mother in the theme of rites of passage?Reference to the story by Doris Lessing

In Doris Lessing's "Through the Tunnel," the tension
between the mother's protectiveness and authority and Jerry's desire for freedom cuts
through the entire narrative.  A widow who must struggle to provide for her boy, Jerry's
mother suffers from the anxieties of having to raise a child without a father, worrying
that she may be doing too much:


readability="5">

Have I been keeping him too close?  He mustn't
feel he ought to be with me.  I must be
careful.



These anxieties of
the mother and her consequent reactive protection, ironically, cause Jerry to wish to
prove all the more that he is a man by asserting his
independence.


When the older boys who swim through the
tunnel reject Jerry for his childishness, Jerry becomes aware that he is too protected
by his mother who has him sit on the "safe beach." He,
then,



knew he
must find his way through that cave, or hole, or tunnel, and out on the other
side.



The tunnel becomes, of
course, symbolic of Jerry's rite of passage from childhood to adulthood. Without his
mother's knowledge, Jerry submerges himself in the tunnel and swims through it, although
he almost does not make it without exploding his lungs.  But, having made it safely,
only suffering a bloody nose, Jerry returns to the villa.  Now, he sees the local boys
diving, but "he did not want them" because he knows that he is now their equal.  Once in
his room, Jerry rests until he hears his mother.  As they have lunch, Jerry boasts only
that he can hold his breath three minutes.  But, secretly, he knows that he has proved
himself a man.

Saturday, September 5, 2015

Why is British victory in the French and Indian Wars a foreshadowing of difficult times ahead in British-colonial relations?

British victory was not as important as American
participation in that victory in foreshadowing future events. Americans had a new sense
of patriotism, but also a sense of Americanism. They had a new vision of their
importance to the Empire, so much so that Benjamin Franklin spoke of a time when the
capital of the empire would be on the Hudson rather than the Thames. There was growing
resentment and distaste by Americans for the British military in response to the
haughtiness of the British towards the Americans, most of whom were volunteers, and the
complete ineptitude of the British at frontier methods of fighting. Recent historical
research has indicated that American fighters in the war felt a moral superiority to
their British counterparts. The harsh punishments imposed on British soldiers and the
cursing, drinking and whore-mongering of the redcoats contributed itself to this feeling
of superiority. This situation was exacerbated when George Grenville, Chancellor of the
Exchequer, was determined to keep British troops in America even though they were
neither wanted nor needed there. Grenville did not want influential British officers
meddling in British politics, so he kept them in the Americas, contributing to the
growing feeling of resentment.


The immense cost of the war
was also a factor, as well as the issue of governance of Western lands. The new monarch,
George III imposed the Royal Proclamation of 1763 on the colonies, forbidding settlement
west of the crest of the Appalachian mountains. This proclamation was not only largely
ignored; it contributed to a growing sense of independence and "separateness" from the
remainder of the Empire. In short, there was a growing sense that the colonists were
Americans, not British. All of these were a result of the French and Indian
War.

Film: 'Crocodile Dundee' directed by Peter FaimanHow are stereotypical roles upheld and challenged?

One of the stereotypes that is both upheld and challenged is the role of the damsel in distress. Sue is supposed to be the delic...