Monday, March 7, 2016

In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, what are some of the flaws exhibited by Gawain and the other members of the court (including the king) before...

In the famous medieval poem Sir Gawain and the
Green Knight
, King Arthur and the members of his court exhibit a number of
common human flaws before the Green Knight makes his appearance.  These flaws include
the following (as found in the Marie Boroff
translation):


  • The king and his courtiers seem
    somewhat immature. They delight in partying and seem to have forgotten the need for
    humility and for true Christian devotion. Little wonder, then, that they are immediately
    described, in the Boroff translation, as “bold boys”
    (21).

  • The king and his courtiers seem to have forgotten
    the true purpose and meaning of Christmas, which should ideally be a time of offering
    thanks to God for the birth of Christ. Instead, they seem to think of it as a time of
    self-indulgent celebration, as when the poet
    says,

readability="8">

. . . the feast was in force full fifteen
days,


With all the meat and the mirth that men could
devise.
(44-45)



  • Admittedly
    Arthur and his courtiers do attend religious services during this period (63-65), but
    the attention devoted to religious worship is minimal compared to the attention devoted
    to having a good time in all the most worldly senses of the term
    (37-70).

  • The court is described in ways that associate
    it, and especially the queen, with luxury (72-80).

  • There
    may be some irony in the description of Guenevere as a “Fair queen, without a flaw”
    (81); certainly readers who knew the later history of Guenevere as an adulteress would
    be likely to find this description ironic.

  • Arthur himself
    is described in ways that make him sound immature (“So light was his lordly heart, and a
    little boyish” [85; see also 89]).

  • More significantly,
    Arthur is associated explicitly with pride (that is, self-centeredness, the root of all
    sin according to Christians): “a point of pride pricked him in heart”
    (90).

In short, Arthur and his court seem to be
in true need of the lessons the Green Knight eventually teaches, especially the lessons
of humility, maturity, and the true meaning of Christmas and the Christian
religion.


Certainly Gawain learns, by the end of the poem,
that the elaborately false humility he displays when the Green Knight first appears
(354-61) is nothing like the genuine humility he feels by the end of the
work.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Film: 'Crocodile Dundee' directed by Peter FaimanHow are stereotypical roles upheld and challenged?

One of the stereotypes that is both upheld and challenged is the role of the damsel in distress. Sue is supposed to be the delic...