Thursday, June 11, 2015

Why do you think Amir states that he never thought of Hassan as his friend in The Kite Runner?

There are a number of reasons why Amir can never fully
accept Hassan as a true friend, and not just as a playmate during his hours away from
school. First, Hassan and Ali are both Hazara, the lowest ethnic class in Afghanistan.
Amir is constantly reminded of Hassan's social status--by classmates, people on the
street and even, more discreetly, Baba himself. Considered valued members of the
household, Ali and Hassan nevertheless live in a mud hut on the property, not within
Baba's spacious home. Although Amir enjoys Hassan's company, it is easier for him to
avoid the scrutiny of others by abandoning the Hazara boy except when it suits him.
Their differences are always visible to Amir: Hassan has a harelip (and Ali is crippled)
and dresses simply in the local tradition; he is illiterate and gullible; and Hassan has
the distinct Mongol features that so easily separates the Hazara from the other tribes
in Afghanistan. As he grows older, Amir finds himself  embarrassed to be seen with
Hassan in public.


Jealously becomes another reason Amir
cannot think of Hassan as a friend. Amir is practically obsessed with gaining the
positive attentions of Baba, and when Amir sees  Baba's own attentiveness of Hassan
growing stronger, Amir's jealousy strikes out at Hassan. It is this streak that moves
Amir to falsely accuse Hassan of stealing, thinking Baba will never trust Hassan again.
Instead, Baba forgives Hassan, and Hassan shows his own loyalty to Amir by refusing to
tell Baba of Amir's transgressions against him. Amir is even jealous of the
few gifts Baba gives Hassan, such as the expensive kite and the payment of the operation
to medically correct the boy's harelip.


Cowardice is yet
another reason Amir has for refusing to call Hassan his friend. Amir doesn't have the
moral fortitude to stand up for Hassan when he is verbally attacked on the streets, nor
does he have the courage to intervene when Assef rapes Hassan. It becomes easier for
Amir to take the cowardly way out in his dealings with Hassan, best exemplified by his
placement of his own birthday presents under Hassan's mattress. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Film: 'Crocodile Dundee' directed by Peter FaimanHow are stereotypical roles upheld and challenged?

One of the stereotypes that is both upheld and challenged is the role of the damsel in distress. Sue is supposed to be the delic...