Monday, February 22, 2016

How would you broadly describe views of life of the characters in Ernest Hemingway's story "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place"?

The personalities and views of life of the three main
characters in Ernest Hemingway's story "A Clean Well-Lighted Place" might briefly be
described as follows:


THE YOUNGER
WAITER


  • Condescending, as in the
    way he slurs his words when speaking to the old
    man.

  • Emphatic, as when he refuses to serve the old man
    another drink.

  • Cocky, as in his confidence in his own
    instant opinions.

  • Shameless, as when he tells the older
    waiter that the old man should have killed
    himself.

  • Materialistic, as in his concern to be
    paid.

  • Impatient, as in his repeated desire to get
    home.

  • Self-confident, as when speaks of his eagerness to
    go home to his wife.

  • Touchy, as when he suspects that the
    older waiter may be insulting him.

  • Occasionally capable
    of thinking of others, as when the narrator says of
    him,

readability="5">

He did not wish to be unjust. He was only in a
hurry.



  • Cruel, as
    when he tells the old man (who fortunately can't hear) that he should have killed
    himself.

  • His view of life
    seems shallow, selfish, materialistic, hedonistic, and immature. He seems to think that
    the world revolves around him and around his needs and
    desires.


THE
OLDER WAITER


  • Perceptive, as when
    discussing the old man's state of mind.

  • Tolerant, as in
    his attitude toward the old man staying
    late.

  • Knowledgeable, as when he explains the old man's
    suicide attempt.

  • Non-judgmental, as when he doesn't
    condemn the old man for trying to kill himself.

  • Capable
    of imagining and appreciating immaterial things, such as the old man's
    soul.

  • Capable of humor, as when he jokes with the younger
    waiter.

  • Aware of his own growing loneliness and
    age.

  • Capable of appreciating order and simple
    pleasures.

  • Thoughtful, as when he speculates on the old
    mna's feelings.

  • Courteous, as when he thanks the
    barman.

  • Troubled, as his apparent "insomnia"
    suggests.

  • His view of life
    seems mature and thoughtful and
    humane.


THE
OLD MAN


  • Capable of despair, as
    his recent suicide attempt suggets

  • Financially
    comfortable (his suicide attempt was not due to a lack of
    money)

  • Lonely, as in the opening
    scene.

  • Clean: the older waiter admires the old man's
    ability to drink without spilling his liquor.

  • Dignified,
    as in the way he drinks quietly and expects no
    sympathy.

  • Respectful:he fails to pay only when he becomes
    drunk, not because he deliberately wants to cheat anyone else. He also thanks the young
    waiter for pouring him a drink.

  • Perceptive, as when he
    senses the transition from daytime to nighttime even though he is blind.

  • The old man's view of life
    seems rooted in the pain of aging and loneliness -- feelings the young waiter cannot yet
    appreciate but which the older waiter has begun to
    understand.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Film: 'Crocodile Dundee' directed by Peter FaimanHow are stereotypical roles upheld and challenged?

One of the stereotypes that is both upheld and challenged is the role of the damsel in distress. Sue is supposed to be the delic...